330-338-5130    

Meet our Team and Testimonials


Our Staff


Jay Cutler
Founder / Attorney

Micah Riley
President and CEO

Becky Goodwin
Vice President - Title

John DePasquale
Director of Operations

Melissa Stoner
Assistant to the VP

Cheryl Sturiale
Senior Title Officer - Commitments

Kym Gregory
Senior Title Officer - Final Policies

Chris Garster
Title Specialist - Final Policies

Tammy Gildersleeve
Senior Account Manager - Midwest USA SFR Institutional Investor

Shelly Polilli
Midwest USA Escrow Officer

Carter Deblock
Midwest USA Escrow Officer

Kathy Foster
Midwest USA Escrow Processor

Katie Doherty
Belden Village/Canton Office - Escrow Processor

Dawn Criswell
North Canton/Green Office Escrow Officer

Cindy Nicola
North Canton/Green Office Escrow Officer

Devin Clark
Northeast Ohio Relationship Manager

Dylan Vinciguerra
Green/Uniontown/North Canton Office Escrow Processor

Jeremy Gilliams
Stow Office Escrow Officer

Rhonda Wymer
Canton and Fairlawn Office Escrow Officer

Brian Beck
Alliance/Carrollton Office Escrow Officer

Beth Cornell
Alliance/Carrollton Office Escrow Processor

Griffin Peyton
Central Ohio/Columbus Region - Account Executive / Sales Manager

Lisa Sulser
Central Ohio/Cincinnati Region - Escrow Officer

Bonnie Schmidt
Central Ohio/Cincinnati Region - Escrow Officer

Nancy Moorman
Central Ohio/Columbus Region Escrow Processing Administrative Assistant

Belinda Bridges
Midwest USA 1031 Investor Account Manager

Nancy Hall
Midwest USA 1031 Escrow Processor

Daulton Ritter
Senior Account Manager - SFR Institutional Investor

Lori O'Hara
Midwest USA Institutional Investor Escrow Officer

Rachel Gilliams
Midwest USA Institutional Investor Escrow Officer

Luzdinia (Lu) Rosario
Midwest USA Institutional Investor Escrow Processor

Johnathan Mizener
Midwest USA Institutional Investor Escrow Processor




Our Offices


Corporate Office

Headquartered in Cleveland, OH,and licensed in OH, AL, PA, IN, MO, MN, KS, KY,
Phone: 330-338-5130 | Fax: 330-493-5312

Belden Village Canton Office

4618 Dressler Road NW,Canton,OH 44718
Phone: 330-491-2725 | Fax: 330-493-5312

North Canton Office

203 Applegrove St NW,North Canton,OH 44720
Phone: 330-491-4111 | Fax: 330-498-3501

Green Office

971 E. Turkeyfoot Lake Road,Akron,OH 44312
Phone: 330-491-4117 | Fax: 330-896-8681

Akron/Fairlawn Office

2800 W. Market Street,Akron,OH 44333
Phone: 330-867-6411 | Fax: 330-836-0478

Stow/Cuyahoga Falls Office

3653 Darrow Road,Stow,OH 44224
Phone: 330-689-5026 | Fax: 330-688-8701

Alliance Office

1370 S Sawburg Ave,Alliance,OH 44601
Phone: 330-829-5454 | Fax: 330-821-9555

Carrollton Office

704 Canton Rd NW,Carrollton,OH 44615
Phone: 330-829-5454 | Fax: 330-821-9555

Dublin - Columbus Office

7240 Muirfield Dr #100,Dublin,OH 43017
Phone: 614.389.0733 | Fax: 614.681.3286

New Albany - Columbus Office

270 E. Main St,New Albany,OH 43054
Phone: (614) 339-4632 | Fax: (614) 339-4660

Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky Office

7074 Harrison Avenue Suite 12,Cincinnati,OH 45247
Phone: 513-824-8822 | Fax: 513-574-0928

Cleveland Independence Office

4401 Rockside Road #212,Independence,Ohio 44131
Phone: 216.270.2450 | Fax: 216.260.9147


Testimonials


Title One is the best title company I have ever done business with. From Micah, Tammy, Shelly, Daulton, Carter, Rachel, and more, our process is always streamlined and we are updated throughout the deal, which always close on time without any hiccups. I would highly recommend using Title One. We switched almost all of our deals to Title One because they blow away everyone else. This is coming from someone who personally closed 194 houses in 2021 - there is no better company to work with. Thanks, Title One, and we look forward to continuing working closely together. Casey.

Casey Oaks from GoGo HomeBuyers (Large Investor)



I am a Realtor and have closed on thousands of properties over my 25 year career. I closed on an investment property today and used Title One for the first time. They were fantastic. It was the smoothest and most efficient closing I have EVER had! Tammy and her team were great communicators. Highly recommend!

Julie Vaughan (Re/Max Real Estate)



Working with Shelly at Title One has been a great experience. Her excellent communication was very impressive - she corresponded in a timely manner EVERY time and NEVER forgot to text, call, or email back. That is hard to come across these days with a title company. Also, their virtual closing went very smoothly. I am excited to do business with Shelly at Title One again! They are also very friendly and professional. Thank you for your service. Also, they even had a preferred vendor referral for me. Very helpful!

Grant Painter (Investor)



I am a Sr. Loan officer for a highly ranked mortgage lender. Some of my purchase loan transactions are done w/ Title One being the title and escrow company involved. Their communication and teamwork is top of the line. The keep every transaction very smooth flowing. They help with what we ask them to and go above and beyond to work directly with myself and the realtor to make sure we all get the transaction closed as needed. As most of you in the real estate, mortgage, title etc. industries know, having that communication and teamwork is of the utmost importance. They are integral at assisting that buyer in achieving their dream!

Bradley Lane



We have used several local title companies over the years; Tammy Gildersleeve is by far the BEST we have encountered. She was accessible and returned calls immediately. She is articulate and answered questions concisely yet thoroughly. She managed the process with precision, yet was flexible and accommodating when we had to make timing changes. Tammy is the consummate professional and a most pleasant person to deal with! I will not hesitate to use her again nor recommend her to friends and associates. Thank you Tammy!

Hazel Beard



I have used Title One Agency numerous times for purchase transactions. Most of my experiences at Title One have been with Cheryl Sturiale & Jacque Hofer. Their service is top notch. Title One always works their schedule so my buyers are not inconvenienced. If my buyer needs to close at 11:00 PM on a Sunday in the middle of a tornado, I'm confident Title One would get it done. Thank you for your service!

Jason Marsh



Prompt, practical, efficient, cost-effective service for our closing, despite being out of state. Tammy Gildersleeve was the great.

David Mitchell



Title One was the agency used when we purchased a home and everything went so smoothly, we decided when it was time for us to sell a home by owner, we would use them again. Kathy Foster couldn't have been more helpful and pleasant to work with. She even went the extra mile to take the check from the proceeds to deposit at our bank because we were out of town! We wouldn't hesitate to recommend Title One and Kathy to anyone!

Tom Grimm



Brian has done the title work on many of my closings. He always does and excellent job. He keeps me informed throughout the process. He is patient in answering questions and explaining things that I am not sure of.The deed is always transferred the day and time that he states. He is also very helpful to the buyers at time of closing answering their questions and explaining each document that needs signed. Again an excellent job and a pleasure to work with.

Kathie Mathie



Brain handled a closing on my home and did an excellent job.. he explained all the paperwork and made sure everything was handled properly. Will always use this title company and would recommend Brian to everyone.

Sandy Azzarella



We were amazed and so pleased at how easily the closing went. Brian is super efficient and organized. Through the whole process he was very helpful, understanding, and quick to respond. Thank you Brian!

Connie Weaver



Brian at Title One Alliance Office handled my closing efficiently and professionally. Quick response to emails and and good communication with my clients. My go to guy in Alliance and should be yours too.

Brenda Jackson



Super people to work with. Very fast , and I know things will be handled correctly! Never a problem never any issues and everything done ON TIME. AAA++++

Gary Blevins



This was a very easy process. Brian was great to work with. I look forward to working with him and Title One (Alliance) again.

Chris Miller



Brian was very helpful with our closing process. Pleasant to work with and very knowledgeable. Thanks for all of your help and patience.

Donna Wilson